Secularism: Staging-Post on the Road Back to Paganism

An article by the Very Rev. Dr. Justyn Terry

Secularism promises a neutral public space in which people of all religions and those with none can live together in peace. This is a compelling vision, which raises the hope that conflicts between all religions and ideologies will be overcome and that a new more advanced civilization will emerge. Who would not be in favor of that?

Over the last hundred years or so, however, that hopeful vision has not materialized. Rather than seeing greater harmony in secular societies, we have witnessed more community breakdown. We also notice that the greatest losses of life in the twentieth century (Mao Tse-tung: 70 million deaths; Stalin: 20-40 million deaths; Hitler: 11-12 million deaths; Pol Pot: 1-2 million deaths…) have been inspired by secular ideologies, not religious ones. The atrocities that human beings commit against each other continue apace, and secularism is at a loss to know what to say about them. “It is the work of a few rogues” sounds less plausible every time we hear it. The incoherence of secularism also means that it cannot withstand determined pressure groups or totalitarian ideologies.

I believe secularism in the West is really a combination of Christianity and paganism, with the proportions shifting over the years from the former to the latter. Secularism does not supply values of its own but borrows them from Christianity (human rights, care for minorities, freedom of speech, toleration of differences, etc.) or paganism (fascination with astrology and ever more extreme forms of entertainment, lower views of marriage, higher views of other relationships, openness to abortion/infanticide, euthanasia, etc.). Credit is rarely given to these sources, and it is only as the proportion of paganism has increased that the true nature of secularism is becoming more apparent.

The strongly Christian content of early forms of secularism gave it a veneer of plausibility. It also made it very hard for Christians to contest it. When we have tried to do so, it seemed we were arguing against many of our own values, which to some extent we were. It has also made us slow to see how secularism has become increasingly antagonistic to Christianity. In the end, the secular claim of neutrality cannot be valid since, “the mind that is set on the flesh is hostile to God…” (Rom 8:7).

At this stage in its development, however, the pagan content is much more obvious. The new secular morality looks increasingly like the old pagan morality. Many of the ethical developments that have been presented as progress look ever more like regress. And whilst first century pagan ethics often included an expectation of judgment beyond the grave, many neo-pagans have no such expectation, leaving them with only a “don’t get caught” morality.

The great missionary theologian Lesslie Newbigin puts his finger on the problem when he discusses “The Myth of the Secular Society” in his classic text The Gospel in a Pluralist Society.

In the 25 years since Munby wrote his book [The Idea of a Secular Society, 1963], we have learned something about the secular society. We have learned, I think, that what has come into being is not a secular society but a pagan society, not a society devoid of public images but a society which worships gods which are not God. But the myth of a secular society remains strong. (p 219f)

Newbigin even wonders if open democratic societies can continue to exist if secularism goes on eroding the roots of the Christian worldview in which they have developed.

The pagan gods are endearingly indulgent, not being paragons of virtue themselves. The price of placating them, however, does seem to be very high, frequently involving the sacrifice of others. The problem is that the pagan gods are preoccupied with themselves and that they tend to “create” people in their own image. They also suffer the significant disadvantage of not actually existing, except perhaps to the extent that they embody demonic powers.

Rodney Stark, Professor of Sociology at Baylor University, charts how the pagan world rapidly turned to Christianity two-thousand years ago when they discovered that the Christian God actually loved them. They experienced God’s love as it was demonstrated by Christians who cared for their abandoned children and who risked their lives to tend to those suffering from plague. This God also enjoys the great advantage of actually existing.

The church has been painfully slow in responding to secularism. But as its pagan face is seen ever more clearly, may we now engage it for the sake of those caught in its thrall, with all the resources of our forbears who, like Augustine, exposed paganism for what it really was and won many to Jesus Christ.

The Very Rev. Dr. Justyn Terry is Dean and President of Trinity School for Ministry
and Professor of Systematic Theology.

He lives in Sewickley, PA with his wife Cathy and their two daughters.

Recommended Posts
Showing 3 comments
  • Anonymous

    Huzzah Justyn!!…Great article and interesting quote from Newbigin. Newbigin’s awesome lectures on ecclesiology in Household of God is worthy reading for this discussion. I can see paganism not secularism creeping into the church and our ecclesial theology. Paganism which historically is Graeco-Roman polytheism is evident in this post-post enlightenment and modern era where the gods of prosperity, with doctrines that are dripping with honey and even a gnostic flavor where the Christian does not see the body as the temple of the Holy Spirit but instead uses the temple for pleasure, is obvious. Secular -humanism was for so long the demon of Christianity in the 70-80’s and I wonder if that was the distraction sent by ole slew foot to keep us from detecting the flood of paganism rushing down the mountain. God Bless you as you serve the Lord Jesus and help create “Biblically minded Anglicans for a global age”. Rev. Martha M. Horn MDiv 2010

  • Anonymous

    Great article, but it left me wanting more I would have liked a bit more substance to the argument, perhaps support from Judaism and Aristotle (especially in regard to absolute truth and the nature of pagan gods), but he makes an intriguing point. Our Athiest and Free Thinking friends will claim he’s being a bit too parochial, thus my desire for a broader discussion and more facts/examples. I think they are there. He does get at the nub of our narcissistic culture though. Rev Mark Nordstrom

  • Anonymous

    Right on Justyn! The subtlety of the creep of Paganism has caught many by surprise and too many who are still in denial. Even if one mentions the name Jesus in secular society (including 12-step groups which originated in the Oxford Group Movement of the 30s) one can be chastised.
    Many other signs point to the demise of Christianity in our current cultural and political climate. Mary Theresa Webb, PhD 1985.